2017 | Dir. Joe Wright | 125 Minutes
"You cannot reason with a tiger when your head is in its mouth!"
In 1940, the Labour Party forces British Conservative Party Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain out of office. Meant to serve as a placeholder for the Conservative Party, the irritable First Lord of the Admiralty Winston Churchill is elected Prime Minister. Despite immense pressure from Parliament and King George VI, Churchill perseveres and refuses to surrender to the escalating might of Germany.
Designed to be a prestige picture in every way, Darkest Hour is frustratingly conventional, lacking in any unique qualities in terms of content and presentation. Nearly the entire film features a murky visual aesthetic meant to accentuate the WWII-era England setting that is more jarring than nostalgic. The narrative depicting Parliament and George VI's objections against Churchill and Churchill's subsequent triumph despite their misgivings is as generic as it sounds as depicted on screen in this feature. The very worst sequence is one invented out of whole cloth in which Churchill converses with common British folk while taking a ride on the London Underground, asking their opinions on the war and the potential negotiations with Germany.
Character actor Gary Oldman's go-for-broke performance as Winston Churchill, fully transformed into the iconic British PM under heavy prosthetics, is worthy of praise, but leaves no room for nuance and is far, far from his best work. Kristin Scott Thomas and Lily James also deliver brilliant performances as Clementine Churchill and Churchill's secretary Elizabeth Layton respectively but their work is ultimately wasted on this picture.
The biggest draw of Darkest Hour is Gary Oldman's astounding portrayal of Churchill. Oldman is excellent but his performance is never subtle and, at points, even distracting. The feature itself is a washed-out paint-by-numbers affair, failing to tell a story meant to be inspiring.
FRAGMENTS
- Legendary character actor John Hurt was initially cast as Neville Chamberlain but was undergoing treatment for pancreatic cancer and passed away in January 2017; incidentally, the real life Chamberlain died from terminal bowel cancer
- Darkest Hour depicts the political administrative challenge of Operation Dynamo, while Dunkirk, also nominated for Best Picture released in 2017, depicts the struggle on the ground, on the sea, and in the air
MCU CONNECTIONS
- Ben Mendelsohn (Talos in Captain Marvel and Spider-Man: Far From Home)
